A Bartender's Guide to Bitters: The Spice Rack of Cocktails
Discover how different types of bitters can transform your cocktails with just a few drops.
Bitters are the secret weapon behind countless classic cocktails—concentrated flavor bombs that add complexity, depth, and balance with just a few drops. Think of them as the spice rack of the cocktail world: a well-stocked collection allows infinite flavor variations and refinements.
What Are Bitters?
Bitters are concentrated alcoholic tinctures infused with botanicals: roots, bark, herbs, spices, and fruits. Originally created as medicinal tonics in the 19th century, they evolved into essential cocktail ingredients that add aromatic complexity and slight bitterness that balances sweet and sour elements.
The alcohol content (typically 35-45% ABV) acts as a solvent, extracting essential oils and compounds from botanicals. Despite the high proof, you use such small amounts (dashes, not ounces) that bitters contribute flavor without meaningfully increasing alcohol content.
Angostura: The Essential Foundation
Angostura Aromatic Bitters are the foundation of any bitters collection. Created in 1824 in Venezuela, Angostura's secret recipe (known to only five people) includes gentian root, spices, and herbs creating a complex, warming, slightly spicy profile.
Angostura is essential for Old Fashioneds, Manhattans, Whiskey Sours (when floated on top), and countless other classics. If you own only one bottle of bitters, make it Angostura. The oversized label on undersized bottle is intentional—a labeling mishap in the 1870s that became iconic branding.
Building Your Bitters Collection
Orange bitters: The second essential. Bright, citrus-forward with subtle spice. Critical for Martinis, adds lift to Old Fashioneds, and complements whiskey beautifully. Regan's Orange Bitters No. 6 is the industry standard.
Peychaud's bitters: Lighter and more floral than Angostura, with distinct anise notes. Essential for Sazeracs, also excellent in champagne cocktails. The bright red color adds visual appeal.
Chocolate/Mole bitters: Rich, dessert-like notes that pair wonderfully with aged spirits, coffee cocktails, and tropical drinks. Fee Brothers and Bittermens Xocolatl Mole are excellent.
Celery bitters: The secret ingredient in extraordinary Bloody Marys and savory cocktails. Also surprisingly good in gin drinks.
Grapefruit bitters: Bright, citrusy, slightly bitter. Perfect for tequila and mezcal cocktails, Palomas, and summer drinks.
Pro Tip
When a recipe calls for 'bitters' without specifying type, it means Angostura aromatic bitters. Orange bitters are always explicitly called out by name in recipes.
How to Use Bitters
Dashing: Most common application. Hold the bottle at 45° and shake sharply downward. One 'dash' should be about 1ml or 6-8 drops, though technique varies by person and bottle.
Atomizing: Spray bitters across the surface of a drink for aromatic impact without heavy flavor. Use a small spray bottle or atomizer.
Rinsing: Coat the inside of a glass with bitters, then discard excess. Used in Sazeracs (Peychaud's) and some Martini variations (orange bitters).
Floating: Add bitters on top of a finished drink for visual appeal and concentrated aroma. Common with Whiskey Sours and Amaretto Sours.
Experimenting with Bitters
Don't be afraid to deviate from recipes. Try adding orange bitters to an Old Fashioned traditionally made with Angostura. Experiment with chocolate bitters in rum drinks. Use grapefruit bitters in place of orange for a different citrus profile.
Layering different bitters creates complexity: an Old Fashioned with both Angostura and orange bitters is more nuanced than either alone. Start with recipes, then adjust to your taste.
Storage and Shelf Life
Thanks to high alcohol content, bitters last indefinitely when stored properly. Keep bottles tightly sealed at room temperature away from direct light. No refrigeration needed.
Over years, some settling or color change may occur, but this doesn't affect flavor. Shake before using if you notice sediment.
Making Your Own Bitters
Adventurous home bartenders can craft custom bitters by infusing high-proof neutral spirit or bourbon with botanicals. Common base ingredients include:
- Bittering agents: gentian root, wormwood, cinchona bark, angelica root
- Aromatics: orange peel, lemon peel, cinnamon, cardamom, star anise
- Supporting flavors: coffee beans, cacao nibs, vanilla, dried fruit
- Spices: clove, allspice, black pepper, ginger
Steep botanicals for 1-4 weeks, strain, add simple syrup to balance bitterness, then bottle. It's a rewarding project that produces truly unique flavors impossible to buy.
Bitters transform good cocktails into great ones. These tiny bottles pack enormous flavor, and a modest collection opens up hundreds of variations on classic recipes. Start with Angostura and orange bitters, then expand based on your favorite spirit and cocktail styles. Your cocktails will never be the same.
